Ten Things We Did (And Probably Shouldn’t Have) by Sarah Mlynowski

5926039634 b2bd593f53 Ten Things We Did (And Probably Shouldnt Have) by Sarah MlynowskiBuy Ten Things We Did (And Probably Shouldn’t Have)
eBook price: $10.99
Publisher: Harper Teen
Format: Hardcover
Reviewer: Melissa on July 21, 2011
Rating: 4 out of 5 stars

When you’re 16, you would probably jump at the chance to live parent free, and April is no exception. In Ten Things We Did (And Probably Shouldn’t Have), Sarah Mlynowski writes an account of two teen girls and the misadventures that are sure to put a smile on your face and laughter in your belly. From lying to their parents (#1) and skipping school (#3) to throwing the party everyone will be talking about (#8) and harboring a fugitive (#7), no one said their adventures don’t get a little out of hand from time to time. But that’s just the way you’ll like it. How will April get through her last semester of junior year when there is a love triangle to unravel, laundry to do, and the looming reality that her life might be falling apart…with every single thing she (definitely, maybe, probably) shouldn’t have done.

When it comes to what appears to be light contemporary YA, I can be a little prejudiced at times. (My review of Natalie Standiford’s Confessions Of The Sullivan Sisters is a perfect example.) With Ten Things We Did, however, the buzz I heard on Twitter and within the blogging community (as well as the fact that the author is from Montreal, Canada where I live) was enough to sell me on picking it up. Mlynowski’s writing and the hilarious situations that April, and to a lesser extent Vi, got themselves into made me enjoy this novel. However, what made me love this novel is how it blends April’s poignant and serious concerns with the rest of the novel’s structure. The result? A book with characters that both adults and teens who are 14 and up alike will relate to and will find completely believable. Once you read this book you’ll have to agree that Mlynowski knows the way teens think.

I’m sure that much has been made about how funny Ten Things We Did is in the blogosphere, but there is more to it than that. It’s the kind of book where you’ll find yourself flying through each of the ten things they did (and probably shouldn’t have) in part because the chapters are longer than most. (I, for one, try to finish chapter before I stop reading, so the tendency I have is to read longer than I would normally.) Of course, there are the many humorous scenes that keep you reading and the romantic, swoon-worthy moments help. But for me, the moments where April is concerned about Vi’s working out habits and her real feeling about her parents agreeing to leave her in Westport when they move across the Atlantic and to Cleveland respectively are what made this novel rock for me. Add to that the fact that April is able to balance her romantic relationship with really strong female friendships, then you end up with a strong female role model for teen girls, even with the “mistakes” she makes.

Overall, Ten Things We Did made me a Sarah Mlynowski fan through and through. I can’t wait to get some time to curl up with her 2010 release, Gimme A Call, which is patiently waiting for me on my bookshelf. If you pick up this book, you’ll be a believer, too as long as you don’t mind the suggestion of sex scenes in your teen fiction. 

Related Posts
5318169048 3df39c38f2 Ten Things We Did (And Probably Shouldnt Have) by Sarah Mlynowski
Buy The Big Crunch Special $11.99 (Regular price: $17.99) Publisher: Scholastic Press Format: Hardcover Reviewer: Melissa on January 25, 2011 Rating: 4 out of 5 stars Boy meets girl. Boy loses girl. Boy finds his way ...
READ MORE
5651677401 96a2c192af Ten Things We Did (And Probably Shouldnt Have) by Sarah Mlynowski
Buy Forbidden Special: $10.58(Regular price: $17.99) Publisher: Simon Pulse Format: Hardcover Reviewer: Melissa on June 28, 2011 Rating: 4 out of 5 stars Lochan and Maya (17 and 16 respectively) have always felt closer than the ...
READ MORE
5707839799 48b28cb074 Ten Things We Did (And Probably Shouldnt Have) by Sarah Mlynowski
Buy So Much Closer Special: $10.49 (Regular price: $17.99) Publisher: Viking Format: Hardcover Reviewer: Melissa on May 10, 2011 Rating: 4 out of 5 stars Brooke knows that Scott is the ONE for her... he just ...
READ MORE
5925479515 3ef690bafb Ten Things We Did (And Probably Shouldnt Have) by Sarah Mlynowski
Many of my readers - the vast majority anyway - live in the US, but what you might not know is that I don't. No, I'm Canadian, so while I ...
READ MORE
The Big Crunch
Forbidden by Tabitha Suzuma
So Much Closer by Susane Colasanti
What’s In My Mailbox?: The July 11, 2011

Subscribe / Share

Article by Melissa Montovani

Melissa has always been a voracious reader of fiction and has an M.A. in English Literature to prove it. Like many other adults, she got caught up in the young adult crossover fiction phenomenon. Now, one of her great joys comes from sharing her love of YA lit on this popular review site. Come with expectations of intellect, magic, and honest reviews, and you won’t be disappointed. Melissa Montovani tagged this post with: , , , , Read 441 articles by Melissa Montovani
  • Adam (YA_Weekly)

    Great review, Melissa. I plan on picking this one up myself, but may start with “Gimme a Call” first; the paperback has an amazing cover that I keep sucking my teeth for having to walk past it at work instead of sit and read. But if I love Mylnowski, I’m down for this one next. 

    When you said the “suggestion of sex scenes”, how explicit are they? I’m trying to get an idea pre-reading it what to say to my parental customers.

  • http://www.yabookshelf.com/ Melissa Montovani

    Thanks, Adam. Glad you liked my review. Would love to know what you think of Gimme A Call once you have a chance to read it as it’s on my to be read list as well.

    They aren’t explicit at all. In fact the sex scenes don’t happen in the narrative. It’s more like you know the characters are planning to have sex or having sex in general, but it never goes into the specifics.

  • http://booklabyrinth.blogspot.com Ashley @ Book Labyrinth

    I just read this one a few days ago and I really enjoyed it. I’ve enjoyed all the Sarah Mlynowski books I’ve read, actually. But I loved how this one was funny and crazy and lighthearted but still had some substance/depth to it.

  • http://www.yabookshelf.com/ Melissa Montovani

    I agree with you 100%, Ashley. The fact that this novel is light at times and makes you laugh periodically is great, but the serious moments were what really made it for me. So glad that I had the chance to read it.

  • Tiffanie Ing

    I’ve been wanting to read this for awhile – I love contemporary YA and I’ll usually grab up almost anything (I did have a similar prejudice to Confessions…but like you said, there was so much more to it than the “blue bloods” theme). It’s not about the light, fun comedy for me – it’s about what the author chooses to explore within that lightness, and how I can relate to both the situations and the emotions that makes good contemporary YA for me. This book has a cute concept, but it sounds like it’s also got depth. That’s what I love. =P 

    I haven’t read any of Mlynowski’s books, but there are so few Canadian YA authors who are making it big right now…so I’m really excited for this one. 

  • http://www.yabookshelf.com/ Melissa Montovani

    Tiffanie, everything you said is what I love about contemporary YA, too. I love when the depth of a novel surprises me. I enjoy other genres, but not all of them do this for me, so more and more, I’ve been turning to contemporary.

    Hope you enjoy it!

YABookShelf On Twitter